There are 5 comments for How instinctive is painting? by Dennis Alter Advice from teachers by Patricia Duthie, Qualicum Beach, BC, Canada The Moscow tennis learning technique could be applied to many areas of learning, not just to sports. Even just imagining oneself doing something correctly must have an effect on the brain. Wasn’t there a basketball coach at SFU who taught this? Yesterday I met artist Carey Anderson who said that when he was teaching self-defense he would emphasize moving slowly in order to learn to kick correctly. Really focusing on correct, fluid movements at first, without having to deal with equipment at the same time, could help non-athletes and nervous artists like myself. Mr. Niven, our high school band teacher used to say, “Perfect practice makes perfect!” I agree that remembering to breathe and working slowly could help a person to develop efficient habits. I think the same could be applied to drawing and painting, especially when beginners lack confidence. Imagine sketching without pencil and paper, perhaps copying the movements of the instructor at work. There are 2 comments for Advice from teachers by Patricia Duthie Learning to chunk by Norman Goldstein, UK The trouble is that most artists get used to a reliable system that tends to give a predictable result. Even those artists who “swing out wildly,” when you really look at their work, they are often working in a fairly narrow range without much sophistication. This is often the case with abstract painters who develop a stroke and keep repeating what has worked in the past. When skills are bunched, or “chunked” as you suggest, there is a greater likelihood that moves so learned will become more habitual. One part of the chunk can be a familiar and safe ploy, but another part of the ploy can be something new. In this way increased complexity and interest can be added to work over a period of time. I am not a painter, but a critic and I see this weakness all the time. The peril of restricting habits by Jean Fournier, San Francisco, CA, USA I encourage my students to experiment with whatever medium they’re working with. Unfortunately, so many artists develop habits around formulas and end up doing the same kind of painting over and over again. A lot of this is due to the market place and how quickly they can put together a show. If you look at a lot of web sites you will discover this for yourselves. This kind of art is more about money and has very little to do with true creativity. It is the death of an artist whether they are musicians or writers, etc. I believe a real artist is willing to explore the vast galaxy of light, color and form rather than lapsing into repetitive painting. I think too much specialization is killing the magic of new possibilities. We have become too specialized as a society as well. Learning is how we continue to grow. There is 1 comment for The peril of restricting habits by Jean Fournier Use of repetition in learning to fish by Doug Pollard, Victoria, BC, Canada Last year I added to my fly-fishing techniques by learning how to spey-cast. I needed to handle the Skeena River and its challenges on an upcoming trip. The instructor, Ian, was very skillful himself, and taught me, chunk by chunk, over a dozen or so lessons, until we put it all together in time for my trip — just like the Spartak tennis academy. Repetition was the key — in fact Ian told me that 1500 perfect repetitions would be needed to get it locked away. Gotta get back to my brush. Not strong on exercises by Tatjana Mirkov-Popovicki, Port Moody, BC, Canada This might be the main culprit that holds me down. I was never strong on exercising, nor was that ever encouraged in my family or even at school. Maybe I was just talented to the worst possible amount — enough to fly through the school with good grades without any effort and without building good working habits. It’s a setback having to rebuild yourself as an adult, but many people have to do it in much worse conditions than mine. I am forever on my journey from a winger to a pro and that’s the fight I will never quit. I still at times just do my best whack at something — kind of bulk rather than chunk. There are 4 comments for Not strong on exercises by Tatjana Mirkov-Popovicki Sparks of Genius by Patricia Rucker, Golden, CO, USA I recommend these letters to my Creative Concepts class at Foothills Art Center in Golden, Colorado. For this last session, I found and used the book Sparks of Genius – The 13 Thinking Tools of the World’s Most Creative People by Robert and Michele Root-Bernstein. Written in 1999, the information is fascinating with great examples of creative people and their tools. The Brain That Changes Itself by Jeff Miller, Orillia, ON, Canada Thanks for chunking and myelin. Suggestion: run don’t walk to bookstore for The Brain That Changes Itself by Norman Doidge, MD. This change has happened to my 45 year old autistic son and his abstract painting. Valuable chunking in art school by Patricia Peterson, New York, NY, USA I studied painting for 3 semesters at Emily Carr College of Art and Design. During that time, I used what you call chunking after deciding that printmaking (namely lithography), which I was studying up until that time due to my love of drawing, was a graduate study because I did not know the basics of 2D compositing and other necessary aspects of well constructed 2D artwork. Each of my paintings at that time embodied a ratio of scale with custom made stretchers (scales of 2×4, 5×7, etc.), color use such as two color complementary, tertiary, monochromatic, or underpainting and so forth. I also did gray studies of master paintings to see the composition of complex works. Each painting also incorporated one of glazing, scumbling, etc. In other words, each painting had delineated problems to work through compositionally, using a ratio, brushwork, brush size, color, contrast, pattern, perspective et al. I settled on custom-made stretchers that embodied the golden section. One of my teachers, Ken Wallace, told me I learned in 3 semesters what many take 10 years to learn. I did not have a body of work that could be exhibited as a show when I graduated but I had an appetite for paint. Then I moved to New York and was overwhelmed by the methods at graduate schools which I faithfully tried to incorporate into my work. Eventually although I understood I could teach myself “life got in my way.” I have never forgotten those early days and the pleasure I had in reviewing masterworks and tackling their methods. Chunking throws one into an area of study, grabbing the brain’s attention like none other. There is 1 comment for Valuable chunking in art school by Patricia Peterson [fbcomments url=”http://clicks.robertgenn.com/chunking.php”]
Interlocking Reflections acrylic painting by Bonnie Kramer |
Archived Comments
Enjoy the past comments below for Painting and chunking…
I didn’t know there was a name for it! I teach voice on the basis of 5 elements. I tell my students to think of the 5 points of a star. You can swivvel a star but there is no real top or bottom to it, even as no one of the five elements in my teaching “code” could be left out,which is not the same as being left to its own devices, since the aim of chunking in sport, art, music etc. is to achieve the perfect balance between the elements. Anyone interested in the 5 elements of vocal technique can write to me at fp-at-faithpuleston.net.
Robert, I don’t have a hesor that can ride off in all directions of the compass at once. But I do have a eoshr that can do that and go up and down too.
Yes, Talent and the discipline to acquire it are very important, but are not creativity. Talent as a tool-kit is about all you get. Your last post made them sound interchangeable and neo-science is always making big claims, so of course they will compress “creativity” into “talent” to broaden their claims. We need a post on what you deeply feel Creativity is and then look at the science.
Robert Genn will be signing books on Saturday April 24th between 1 and 3 pm at Canada House, 201 Bear St, Banff, Alberta, Canada. He’s shy, but he’d love to say hello.
Just a quick note to tell you how much I enjoy your letters and how it has both cheered me up and inspired me. I paint, not as often or well as I think I should, and very spasmodically at the best of times. Your letters help me forgive myself and keep on keeping on.
Robert, you just brought a big wide smile to my face after a particularly difficult day…I read all your letters with immense enjoyment and have never written to you before but your last line about your “hesor” was so amusing, I just had to comment..Keep these wonderful and very informative letters coming..You probably don’t realize how some of us look forward to them.
Now that I have your wonderful book of all your letters, I have no need of all the letters I have printed out and they are slowly helping to warm our house. Thank you.
Thank-you for these missives. I’m painting in a coastal outpost in B.C., and these thought provoking letters in my inbox are creative food and fuel. What you do matters.
The other day I had to go into town for a dentist appointment so my wife was looking after things at the workshop. There had been an inquiry about stretching a canvas but usually people want things done yesterday and for nothing so I didn’t take much notice. Anyway my wife phoned me to say that a woman had been in with the most beautiful painting of three scantily clad ladies. The picture had been cut from the frame because she had smuggled it out of her country when fleeing an uprising. Apparently the new regime had looked upon the artists work as pornographic and destroyed everything they came across. I am just waiting for her to come back and was looking on the web for articles on relining when I came across your site. I had already decided that it was such a wonderful story I would not want it tainted with such mundane issues as commerce and would do it for free.
Take a chunk of your brain, the one that you think is most important and vital to keep you thinking you are so great and start making a fool of yourself. I have seen more artists improve their skills and work by replacing seriousness with childish gestures. The greats of the century have already spoken, if you want to break through engage in abstract for 50 years and then, and only then, maybe, you can give it your best shot to paint your first landscape.
I’m reading the Prado Museum book about Joaquin Sorolla and he was told “when you’re too proficient with your right hand paint with your left.” Not that I’m too proficient, but I am going to try it today. Something about stimulating the other side of the brain and getting away from mechanical strokes.
We are in a back eddy of the growth of our civilization. Lots of people nowadays have had it easy for so long that they don’t think it is necessary to learn proper techniques. In pursuits where results can be measured, like golf, tennis or chess, proper learning is still in vogue. But a society cannot live on golf, tennis and chess. Visual art needs to pull up its socks and yes, I agree, learn to chunk. UK
From poet Philip Booth: “Writing poems is not a career but a lifetime of looking into, and listening to, how words see.” Dont you love those lines; how words see! He also said, “I think survival is at stake for all of us all the time. Every poem, every work of art, everything that is well done, well made, well said, generously given, adds to our chances of survival.”
I remember a catchy headline in a newspaper once that said “Beckham as Brainy as Einstein” – the point being that both exhibited different (equally valid ?) forms of intelligence. Beckham’s ability to kick a football was essentially learned muscle-memory that stemmed from years of practice. It was a “learned” ability and that when in a stressful situation this ability became almost automatic allowing perfect execution. Unfortunately I play football like Einstein and paint like Beckham but I think I’m learning.
Hi, that is very interesting. I am going to try to do more small and fast paintings. I am enjoying these emails
I know one thing, my work took a big leep forward when I got a stutio and started painting five days a week. Joy
I wonder if we are better off not knowing anything about an artist as a person. I’d never heard of Mark Tobey when I first saw his work a number of years ago featured along with other Northwest artists in the Seattle Art Museum. It immediately struck me as much better than most of what I’d seen recently and I liked it a lot. There is a big difference between being arrogant and having NPD.
I am sorry to say, I am not impressed with Mark Tobey’s Paintings. there must be somethings wrong with my eyes. for me there should be design or something .looked at the other paintings posted and I think they are wonderful
When you learn a dance you practice and practice until your muscle memory takes over, you barely think about the steps and just perform with emotion and expression. The same must be true for people who play an instrument, sing, or play a sport – after much practice one can then tap into instinct. The same must be true for artists who practice every day.