Archived Comments
Enjoy the past comments below for Mountain rules…
The fundamental rules give us the dance floor upon which we can dance. Regarding Rule #1, I use a light tint of yellow ochre/raw sienna mixed with the primer. When that’s dry, I like to mix another light “imprimatura” with a little Liquin for translucency to use as a wet tone.
Yes, rules are meant to be broken, but some rules are so basic that it seems a shame to ruin one’s life by constantly forgetting them. A toned ground, for example, is like putting your pants on before you go out.
Thank you, that is good information, I will follow it. I am a watercolor person but into acrylics, too.
I like that comment about working like a bee in an Alpine meadow. I always thought it was ADHD that made me do that. But it does keep you from only finishing one part of the painting.
I like the rules – I do some acrylic art but a lot of watercolor too and the rules make sense. Right now, rule 5 is the one I am enjoying most. During my disability, fine motor skills were impaired and the effect of the extra work it took to do a thing was to turn a watercolor into sculpture on the paper sometimes :-D Fit and fine again, I discovered, to my horror, that the tendency to sculpt with my paintbrush had become a habit. So the work from me now is the result of hard work “lightening up” :-D
Great tips. I always tell my students that the first rule of art club is there are no rules, and the second rule is don’t use black. Now I’ll have to add these as well.
I have started too many paintings in the Rockies with the mid and back ground only to paint that luscious emerald green lake in the foreground and realize in horror that the shore line is a boring straight line from one side of the canvas to the other. So taken in by the beauty that the basic needs of composition were forgotten. Maybe I will start with the foreground next time and cheat away until it works.
Very timely, as I’m leaving Sunday for a week long workshop with Marc Hanson in Longmont CO..lots of mountains and streams..intimidating for a small town midwestern artist. Mishawaka, In, USA
What a life!–inhaling the gifts and waiting for our painting to speak to us! I simply love it!
I really like this one! :) Well-written. Nothing else to add today, just a big hug! Slovenia
After reading your rules I realized I needed to add a few of my own, and I kept going. That’s when I realized what you were up to. Thank you.
I would say rule 1 + a concept + rule 5 and (in the studio or outside) ‘Bob’s your uncle” MT
I think my many years in the moutains of Whistler allowed the feeling of the place to become embedded. Now I just paint from my memories of how it felt and try to utilize colour and value to convey the feelings I remember. I like the rules but do get into the rhythm of the painting and hope they work their way into my neurons. We really do have to paint our way to find our path.
Art is one of the few professions where you don’t need to follow any rules, as is evidenced by the wide range of incompetent work we constantly see around us.
Larry, the first workshop I took, the instructor invoked the rule: don’t use black. So I didn’t. Several years later at another workshop that rule was challenged by a different instructor. Have you ever tried Ivory black with Cad yellow? Delicious greens. But too bad about that ‘don’t use black’ rule. Buried in my psyche, it is like being a young adult in the earlier 1960s and living with the guilt of the established paradigm that “nice girls don’t”. Hard to alter thinking patterns and now I have to almost force myself to use black which can indeed be very beautiful under the right circumstances. So go ahead. Break the (black) rule(s)!
Same thing happened to me with black. It was forbidden, then later offered as a good tool by another, and I still have trouble using it. The classical painters use(d) it with relish and their work is amazing.
The trouble is that art schools these days leave students with few skills and fewer rules. As a matter of fact unruliness is encouraged and applauded. There is not much room in the art universe for the truly unruly, but still lots of room for competence.
Michael Cowan’s remarks (above) are nonsense. Clever, competent art (particularly painting) is a dead duck.
The whole business of schools is now being studied and reassessed. Findings include the stifling of creativity and invention in the traditional system. In programs like 20/20 young inventors are paid not to go to university just to get their inventions knocked out of them. MOOCs are also changing the face of education and not all of the old guard can see it coming. It seems we get our best ideas when we’re climbing our own mountains.
This is awesome — these rules answer the question — “Whats wrong with this?” Thank you Robert !
For me there are no rules, I paint with acrylics and because I like strong contrast, I love to use black. As someone has already mentioned it makes some beautiful dark greens mixed with cad yellow etc.
Robert’s rules are like learning scales on a piano. Great concertos are built on this. Only fools and mad dogs would avoid these basics.
I’ve been forty years discovering that the queen of all colors is black. – Henri Matisse I, too, love black…
I don’t paint like this so I’m looking forward to giving it a serious go. I have a feeling it’s going to solve a one or two (or more) things I seem to always struggle with. On the theme of black, I use Spinel Black (PBL26) which is a bit rare as far as shop tube paint goes but it’s readily available as a pigment. I prefer it because it’s pretty much neutral – the most neutral black I believe.
I just have to laugh,,, I haven’t been painting long enough to have any rules ,,, Ignorance is bliss,,, though I do know that if i intend to get some place i have never been, directions are good. The idea that if i want want the results,,, do what they did get what they got,,, like what has been said already big differance between trueths and rules,,, I didn’t know that black is bad or good ,,, i use it for my ground,,, it works ,,, Thomson used orange,,, it works,,, I supose the general idea is an open mind and you can’t do new things without doing new things
First Light on the Harbor oil painting, 18 x 24 inches by John Cosby, Laguna Beach, CA, USA |
Great painting, great example.