Archived Comments
Enjoy the past comments below for Stand up…
My synapses fire much stronger when I’m on my feet. Even when I sit to work on small, fine details, I’m on the edge of the (wheeled) chair, ready to kick it back when the spirit strikes. The tape-on-the-floor “lunging” idea is great.
Absolutely. I’ve often said that you look like what you sit in. I never had a bad back until I became a computer graphic artist. So I stand up a lot. It gets painful sitting too much. And painting often feels like I’m attacking the canvas. I parry and thrust. It’s fun for the outset of a painting when you don’t want to bury yourself in detail and you want an overall view. Especially when painting plein air. But I don’t recommend the behind the line thing. You could really hurt yourself that way – and have a lousy painting to boot. So en garde! and work more than just the brain muscles.
p.s. Churchill is really a bad example. Only good genetics had to have kept him from dying of ‘consumption’ early on. Really. Bad cigars and cheap booze is much better for you. Then you don’t want to consume either one.
What you say is so important…if you paint cranky and stiff it encroaches upon your creative ability. Years ago I went to a yoga class where the middle aged tutor was as limber and flexible as a teenager – I forget all of the exercise names etc., but what I did keep was the idea of keeping flexible – everything in the body that gets scrunched up, including fingers and wrists, needs to stretch. I think I may have invented a few exercises of my own in the process…I have names for them sort of, but, not very yogi-ish.
You are so right Robert! I particularly enjoy painting on large canvasses which enables me to stand. Placing my easel a couple of feet from my palette, the movement back and forth give me a certain type of momentum, which feels a bit like dancing. Its joyous! I highly recommend it.
Besides being good for your body, standing to paint produces benefits to the painting itself. You paint looser and quicker with more energy of movement embedded in your painting strokes. I wear a path in my carpet as I go back and forth between my viewing distance and painting distance!
Brandy and cigars? Congratulations. I do enjoy this myself at times and as for the lunging part — I’m going to put lunging into a study of my own. I wonder what a piece would look like if it was a series of lunges? How would it be with music — lunging with wisps of wet brush awaiting canvas? Would the work then be considered a Lunge style of art? Would they consider calling it LungeArt? — Lunge Art – how to be a cast out with reel ins. Artist, some just taking things a little too far and yet…the possibilities are endless.
Well, in defense of those who do not lunge at their work…I doubt we’d have had the great illuminated manuscripts of the Middle Ages if those monks had been lunging instead of focusing on finely executed, exquisite detail of miniature painting. I believe they perched on high stools. Big, loose and bold, isn’t the only style of painting. However, I have to admit that although I usually sit to paint, I always stand to draw —that’s where I do the spontaneous part of my work. But I like to think it carries through.
I’m the opposite of Caroline — I sit to draw, but stand to paint all but the smallest painting details. My arms don’t seem to make good brush strokes when I’m sitting down. Besides, you get drowsy and stiff faster when you’re sitting.
I stand to paint my watercolours and keep my wine on the countertop about 10 steps away, my version of lunging!
Stepping Back is the first lesson I teach my students, and the one most ignored, that is until I walk up behind them and say “Okay, Step Back! Now we can see what is working or not”. Myself I am exactly like the workshop instructor, paint a couple of strokes; step back; couple more; step back…….keeps me slim and aware of what is going on in my work.
I suppose I could as easily stand up to paint, if I raised my easel, , but stepping back is not a problem, because I am constantly bouncing out of my chair. I do limbering up exercises, go for walks before or after a painting session. So I’m really moving around quite a bit, which I guess upholds the “theory.” The wine is for after I’ve finished, for the contemplation period. Otherwise, I might become too contemplative to get any work done.
I’m one who stands/paces while painting; cannot do it sitting down!! However, its really hard on the joints–back, hips, legs……..wherever your weak spot is, it’ll hurt there. I’ve found padded flooring helps, and so does yoga, but not enough. Any solutions for this?
While I have nothing against standing there are some disadvantages. If you are to stand while painting expect varicose vein’s later in life. Add to that many who stand are standing on the wrong surface i.e. cement floors. While standing and moving back and forth are beneficial not only to your health but also the quality of your work, other extremities can suffer. Bunions and calluses may develop if you are in the wrong shoes. I’m sure Mr. Churchill dictated while smoking, pacing to and fro but I will bet he did so standing on a plush carpet. Padding is essential if you are to stand. Also having the space to move back and forth isn’t always available. As a result if we stand in one spot we don’t get the true benefits of this exercise. It’s the “moving” part that holds the secret of heart health. From the many sources I’ve read, John Singer Sargent stood and paced back and forth incessantly though he used this practice to exorcise demons which prevented him from achieving his goal. To each his own I guess.
Well, I stand to paint and pace back forth with my hand mirror. And I celebrate my daily work at the easel with a large glass of red wine at about six while washing my brushes. And I am a tidy 130 pounds and 5′ 3″. With three solo shows as feathers in my cap, guess my regimen is working. So, Robert, keep me on my toes !!!
When I was first taught art, most of the instructors had us used the tape on the floor method. I thought that was common practice. Only after I got out of that school and started taking workshops I noticed that it wasn’t. Now, after several years of lazy painting (+ office work), I am noticing impact of health and waistline. Thanks for the reminder to go back to a healthier practice. You may be saving some lives here.
I have a request I hope you will be able to satisfy. About 3 months ago you wrote a great “check list” to go over when viewing a painting. Particularly ones own work. Seems there were about 20 different points to pay attention to. Is this description enough to stir your memory banks? Being a loyal reader of your blog I want to let you know how much you are appreciated. I hope everyone lets you know that enough to keep the fire in your belly.
‘I recently heard of a workshop instructor who gets his students to lay down a tape on the floor six or eight feet from the canvas. He encourages students to stand behind the line and lunge forward to make strokes, then immediately get back to survey the situation.’ This reminded me of something: there was supposedly a line worn into John Singer Sargent’s carpet because he ran back and forth in front of his paintings so much. Apparently, he used the ‘sight size’ method, which I’m not quite clear on. Perhaps you could devote a future column to this topic?
I thought Churchill owed his success to the naps he took. My grandfather used to say, why stand up when you can sit down and why sit down when you can lay down.
I hope you enjoyed the cigars and brandy. Also (about stand up painting) I had a teacher tell me to always stand instead of sitting. He says to paint as though it were a dance. It keeps your body healthy and your brain working better.
When I hear of things like lunging at the canvas etc I often think gimmick. There is a time and place for everything….. For some reason an old Youngbloods song keeps running though my mind. Turn, Turn, Turn. Focus on what you are doing at the time and do it well. Don’t make painting your exercise too (Though of course you could decide to do plein-aire and take a day hike with your tools and canvas on your back…….)
I paint to lively music, flamenco, orchestra rock, even belly dancing music. I am guilty of dancing when I am painting. I think the passion I feel from the music is reflected in my work. I also paint to the fast beat of the music- sometimes the music is so fast that it is impossible to think or plan- I am caught up in the passion of it and the subconscious takes over. This is when my best work happens… the magic I cannot explain or even re-create.
I like standing up to paint large watercolours because it allows you to go…. literally….. with the flow!
I used to sit down all of the time when I was working on watercolors. However, learning how to mass paint encouraged me (by my instructor) that I was supposed to keep stepping back to look at how the value masses related. So, I pretty much am required to stand at the easel. It was tiring on my knees at first, but got much stronger standing there for hours. Plus, it helps for my plein air work, also.
I’d like to take your advice Robert, about standing up and pacing around, but I’m busy getting ready for the end of the world tomorrow. Bye.
Damn. Wrong again.
When I was studying painting at the Alberta College of Art (Calgary, Alberta), my instructor insisted that all the students stood while painting. The advantage to this is that you get into the habit of standing back to see the whole picture (as it were) and aren’t there with your nose to your painting missing out on the full composition. 14 years after graduating, I still always stand at my easel and find myself moving back and forward without even thinking about it. However, I don’t think that standing has led to any positive changes to my weight. (Oh well) I must say however that after seeing you at Painter’s Lodge (British Columbia) with your very comfy looking “sitting-easel”, I find it difficult visualizing you in a standing position!
As I continue to find the balance in life both standing and sitting down, I want you to know that receiving emails from you is part of my nourishment. Thank you. P.S. Happy Birthday.
Stand up……..as recommended by the researcher at The Mayo Clinic is good and I value that facility so much I have an appointment at Rochester next week. I have all the art equipment I need in my studio, and if all goes well with my medical challenge, I plan to be painting standing up, sitting down, lunging forward with wc/acrylic/oil and stay on the move……in which case I’ll need to sign up for your “mini website”. I’ve got Mexican handmade Amate paper acquired a few months ago just waiting. Your letters inspire and excite my creative juices! bainjo9@gmail.com
I tried dictating, carrying a small recorder like a mike, and it works. I went ouside, went for a walk in a private place, spoke when I thought up sentences, thought some more, even for a while. Then spoke again. The hardest part was remembering just how the last sentence ended off.
Thank you so much for your letters. I always enjoy them, profit by them, and often share your wisdom with good friends. Happy birthday. With admiration and good wishes. Pinson, Alabama rahillustrator1@mac.com
I have always stood to paint mostly because I like to move around and when using pastels, easier to reach them. Years ago, I ordered an “artist’s back weight” from Jerry’s Artarama (have no idea if they still sell them.) It helps one stand up straight when painting and has the additional benefit of weight bearing pressure on the spine for osteoporosis prevention. One could also use a small backpack with a book or two in it. It is most comfortable to wear it up as high as possible. Is it a pleasure to wear? No. But if you get dizzy and pass out because of standing so long, at least you will fall backwards and not mess up your painting.
I am sure that there many artists who because of foot problems find it difficult to stand for any amount of time. Therefore I sit and it does not have any negative impact on my art. If I were to stand the pain would interrupt my concentration. I have had to deal with this problem for many years and thankfully there are several portable chairs for en plein air. Inside the studio I use an office chair with casters outfitted with a cushion form another chair. So I have a choice-stand and be unable to work or sit and create. I know that I am not alone in dealing with this situation..
Without even consciously thinking about it, I stand up to paint. Even if I start off sitting down, I leap to my feet eventually, occasionally to the detriment of the chair, which has gone flying a few times. I used to make theatre costumes, and worked standing up unless I was actually stitching on a machine.
I often step back from my french easel. So often, and so reflexively, that I never, ever paint with my back to a nearby body of water.
That convinces me. I have a small room, with a french easel, which I trip over if I stand to paint. So I am going to get an H-easel so I can stand and save the other for outdoors.
I get in miles of walking when I am finishing a painting…especially a large painting. I stand back about ten feet from my painting, during the last few weeks of painting and then walk forward to make a stroke…and then back ten feet to take another look. Its the only way that I am assured that my images/colors/composition are working for the entire painting. I wouldn’t even think to sit down to paint. That stifles the flow of energy. Your brains end up in your feet.
I sit to paint… or do I? I sit in a draftmans chair… I raise it up to suit the height of my canvas… and scoot back and forth ad lib. Woiks for me!!
I too have often found sitting down at an easel or table very resticting; having the urge to move around. I find that using an exercise ball, instead of a chair or stool, suits me wonderfully. I can roll around, bounce thereby creating movement. The exercise ball helps strengthen your core, balance, and improve your posture. Just make sure its the right size that you can place your feet on the ground and comfortably reach the table.
Fun news is good , I will enjoy standing even more now when I paint.
Great advice but I paint in watercolor. no throwing that from a tape line onto a canvas. However I definitely agree with your theory, I am in need of a knee replacement so no moving about or standing for any length is advised at this time. Diet seems to be my only alternative. I am an artist too, so I do appreciate the advice; I also sit all day at work. Waiting to win a lottery so that I can quit this sedentary job and paint full time.
Sunny stream oil painting, 16 x 20 inches by Doug Downey, Springdale, Newfoundland, Canada |
Wonderful painting! Love the light and the ducks.