Lester, Mary and Jack

Dear Artist, Three others hang out with me when I’m painting in our garden. Lester and Mary were around here last year. This year they’ve brought along an oversized teenaged layabout with an annoying voice. Jack is often on his own, but Lester and Mary, who may be married, spend a lot of time strutting about, discussing, among other things, Jack. The parents are a bit co-dependent, but they like each other and seem smugly contented with their day-to-day routine. Lester, Mary and Jack are crows. Their imminent arrival is often preceded by a loud smack on our patio. Lester and Mary will be dropping beach clams onto our hard tiles and breaking them nicely open, often near to Jack, who has been standing around, grumbling. This act of creativity seems wasted on Jack, as he takes forever to walk over and check out his take-out. No matter what the folks do for Jack, he’s a complainer. Several years ago, Teresa Amabile, researcher and professor at the Harvard Business School, completed a study which led to “The Six Myths of Creativity.” In it she tore apart six popular ideas: “Creativity only comes from creative types.” “Money is the main creative motivator,” “Time pressure fuels creativity,” “Fear forces breakthroughs,” “Competition beats collaboration,” and “A streamlined organization is a creative organization.” Amabile opts for more immediate and joyful creative motivators. In the business of money, for example, she found that reward didn’t count as much as most people think. It seems folks get creatively engaged when they have a sense of playful progress. “People are most creative when they care about their work and they’re stretching their skills,” she says. And it happens over a period of time — one day to the next in a cooperative environment can produce more creativity than the hot expectation of a bonus. I’ve come to the conclusion that Lester and Mary do the clam-drop just because they know how. Maybe they were similarly lethargic when their folks were giving clam-drop demos. But somehow they figured it out, and they got to like doing it. I wonder if it warms their hearts to be among the more advanced, tool-using animals? I wonder, considering Jack’s indifference, if the production of dinner comes as a byproduct of fun? Best regards, Robert PS: “One day’s happiness often predicts the next day’s creativity.” (Teresa Amabile) Esoterica: Those of us who think we create best when under pressure or when meeting deadlines should think again. Amabile found that “time pressure stifles creativity because people can’t deeply engage with the problem. Creativity requires an incubation period, people need time to soak in a problem and let the ideas bubble up.” You can read management guru Bill Breen’s famous interview with Teresa Amabile here. A note of caution — none of the subjects of Amabile’s now classic research were crows.   Savasana and ‘effortless effort’ by Linda Saccoccio, Santa Barbara, CA, USA  

oil painting, 18 x 14 inches
by Linda Saccoccio

Seems true, incubation, cessation, rest periods are needed for transformation to occur, as in creation. In yoga we are warned not to eliminate savasana, the corpse pose, where no effort is needed and we assimilate the fruits of the practice. With ease and balance grace arises. With steady practice we achieve through a kind of effortless effort. Yoga is a great foundation for healthy habits in the studio. Both are good for developing alertness that is needed when clams are falling from the sky too.     Creativity is two thoughts colliding by Peter John Reid, Chatsworth, ON, Canada  

“Promise of a day”
original painting, 30 x 60 inches
by Peter John Reid

In my experience, creativity comes forth under all conditions, alone or together, relaxed or under duress, interested and disinterested. I believe wide interests help feed creative thought but I think the only true criteria are two thoughts colliding. Some may get more, others less; the luck is that happening at the right time. I actually imagined the wheel but I was a tad late. P.S. Who was the mother of invention? There is 1 comment for Creativity is two thoughts colliding by Peter John Reid
From: Brenda — Aug 30, 2011

I love this! Where is ‘Chatsworth’? Do you do workshops?

  The value of inspiration by Bill Skuce, Sooke, BC, Canada  

original painting
by Bill Skuce

“The laziest people in the world are the most inventive” is a tongue-in-cheek expression I sometimes use in a self-deprecating way in response to a remark like, “Great idea!” referring to an innovative solution I’ve come up with. The obvious truth contained in the remark refers to the innovations industry and businesses are seeking and sometimes reward employees for: the creative shortcut (Time is money). Along with her in-depth study of creativity, I think Theresa Amabile might have done well to include a study of “inspiration,” which relates to but does not, it seems to me, equate with “creativity.” Although not removed from creativity, it is, I believe, the concept painters more easily associate with their own processes. There are 2 comments for The value of inspiration by Bill Skuce
From: Susan Kellogg, Austin TX — Aug 30, 2011
From: LD — Sep 01, 2011

And another thought…most machine inventions were the result of someone looking to do a task with less effort (laziness?) lol

  Making it too easy for the kids by Suzette Fram, Mapel Ridge, BC, Canada  

acrylic painting
by Suzette Fram

Having raised 2 children and now being blessed with several grandchildren, the thought came to my mind when reading about the clam-drop: Are we making things too easy for our kids? Are we robbing them of the value of figuring things out for themselves and are they learning the lesson that you have to work hard to get what you want, and not wait for it to be handed to you?         The foundation of productivity by Lisa Chakrabarti, Los Angeles, CA, USA  

“Liquid Embar Maple”
28 x 13 inches
by Lisa Chakrabarti

According to Amabile, creativity needs the right environment and most people are naturally creative. What Amabile doesn’t factor into her equation is that creativity without hard work is a lot like ‘dead equity.’ The truly creative perform under a variety of environments, some of which can hardly be called ‘nurturing,’ and to imply monetary reward isn’t a factor is plain-out ludicrous. Money may not be the engine that drives people to create art initially, but it drives them to become more productive and efficient. Many people have creative ability — but they lack the effort or the commitment to do anything with it. It takes hard work. An expectation of the ‘perfect’ environment or situation is a lot like waiting around hoping you’ll be discovered by Hollywood. It’s not likely to happen. While no one wants to work with someone figuratively ‘holding a gun’ to their head, the feel-good playfulness about which Amabile writes may have something to do in part with the reason that in the U.S. we hardly produce anything anymore. People just want to have fun and an easy time. Well, not all work is fun — even work you love. Those of us who seriously engage in art know it is challenging, but also sometimes infuriating and sometimes terribly disappointing. It takes years to “get good.” It is the journey of a lifetime, as your bi-weekly letters repeatedly remind us. Some skills molder if not frequently used and refreshed. There’s an old maxim that says the things that are the most worthwhile are the most difficult to accomplish. Amabile does not seem to address this at all — and I believe it is the foundation of productivity. There are 3 comments for The foundation of productivity by Lisa Chakrabarti
From: Jackie Knott — Aug 30, 2011

Lovely painting.

From: Dottie Dracos — Aug 30, 2011

I, too, love your submitted artwork — and your comment.

From: Jim Oberst — Aug 30, 2011

My experience through my 68 years is that people are working HARDER and having LESS FUN than they ever used to. When I started my engineering career, it was a great pleasure – I was given the tools I needed and the time to do my work. When I finished my career, it was pressure, pressure, pressure, with the quarterly results the only thing that mattered. I was glad to escape. I see my children KILLING themselves at their jobs and their home and family responsibilities. I guess you live in a different world than I, Lisa.

  Returning meadowlarks by Jill Musser, Longmont, CO, USA  

“She disagrees”
oil painting, 12 x 10 inches
by Jill Musser

Last June, while painting in the barn, two days in a row, two juvenile meadowlarks came in through the big, open door, perched on the same place on the same beam both days, chirped a lot, watched me and watched their mother flying around outside looking for them in a very agitated way. They finally, after half an hour, went back out to join her. Yes, the very same act, for two days. I think birds may like repetitive behavior, as in your description of Lester, Mary and Jack. This may have little to do with creativity, but it was a fun experience with these happy creatures — while painting! Maybe I warmed their hearts, they warmed mine — fun and nature does enhance the creative mood!     Gulls do it by Barbara, WA, USA   I sorely miss our comical, boisterous sea gulls on Long Beach Island, New Jersey, where I grew up and spent most of my life. It’s an island eighteen miles long and only one mile wide. Our house was just a block away from the Atlantic Ocean to the East and one block away from the Manahawkin Bay to the West. I miss those scavengers every August. Clam season for those buggers. They would pick up one of those razor clams off the water’s edge on the ocean beach and fly over our 2-story flat-top roof, and splat. The poor clam didn’t know what hit him. Talk about a headache! That gull, by no means a dummy, knew just how high up in the sky to go, so the shell would open up from impact. It would make a ‘thud,’ and quite annoying, on our roof. It wouldn’t take long before several more joined their buddies. Crafty little devils, but clever enough with their cuteness. This would go on for days. Every day and for a couple of hours once they started. It only happened to our house! We were the ones with the flat-top roof. Neighbors across the street would be entertained. Their roof had a pitch to it. The seagulls knew exactly which roof! That ruckus would go on until their bellies got full. The dog would bark, of course, but that turned into a false alarm — there wasn’t anyone at the front door. The first time it happened to us, we all got out of the house. But we heard the squawking Gulls overhead, in their feeding frenzy, long before we got out far enough to look up to determine what all that commotion was about. Once we knew, it was just a noisy nuisance. You couldn’t read, watch television, carry on a conversation or sleep. So when that certain time of day came, we would just take our pooch for a nice long walk on the beach for a couple of hours. There was not one thing you could do about it, either. They had us over a barrel, bigtime! They even sounded like they were laughing! My grandpop would get the extension ladder out every spring and sweep off the roof. All the clamshells would land in the driveway. Then the kids got to fill up grocery sacks. Fun times.   Squawk! by Marian Kemp, Powell River, BC, Canada   I’m puzzled. What is the connection with these 3 crows and the 6 ideas about creativity? While I’m a good listener, very intelligent and empathetic (chuckle!!!), I confess to being a bit literal-minded. I like all “i”s dotted and “t”s crossed, and the flow/logic of a theme to be rather linear, I guess you could say. So, I’m still puzzled. Your theme is very interesting, and I’ll look at it again, but I’d be interested in your response. (RG note) Thanks, Marian. Like water dripping on my head, I kept hearing the smack, smack of the falling clams as I was painting and I thought, “This must mean something.” Maybe I’m not very smart but I started to think how marvelously creative were the birds, and how the roots of creativity were still a mystery and the subject of dispute. Then I thought about Teresa Amabile’s now famous, research-based findings on the origins of creativity, and I thought many of our readers would have probably not heard of her ideas, so I thought I might drop the six myths she discovered on people’s heads, and I asked the crows if I could do this, and they all squawked in unison and I thought that meant it would be okay.    

Archived Comments

Enjoy the past comments below for Lester, Mary and Jack

From: Marvin Humphrey, Napa Valley — Aug 25, 2011

money can result from creative skills being stretched, though true satisfaction comes from realizing that achievement. Let’s hope that Jack can “get it” from his parents, that a lot of good can come as a by-product of fun.

From: Daniela — Aug 25, 2011

I so like that, Robert, “a sense of playful progress”, that lovely process that eliminates even the sense of time or the need to explain yourself, you are so enjoying being lost in it.

From: Jean McLaren — Aug 26, 2011

I belong to a great group of people on the lovely island where I live. We meet on Tuesday and Friday mornings and I rarely miss going. We have a large bright room with big tables and everyone has their favourite place. There are a lot of artists on Gabriola, but or group shares our ideas. Because I do mostly acrylic/abstract, most people scratch their heads at what I do but they are almost always supportive. We have several shows a year and the community come and look and sometimes buy even now in this recession (do I dare say that word?) But most of all we paint because we love it even though the paintings stack up at home. I also paint at home but the fun and chatter with our group is something I wouldnt miss. Incidentally we have 3 members who are over ninety and I am 84. I started painting when I was 70 and I am not about to stop for a long time.

From: Wilma Hargetter-Brace — Aug 26, 2011

My breakthroughs tend to come when I’m not looking for them. Sometimes when I least expect any positive outcome.

From: Paula Timpson — Aug 27, 2011

digesting days is artwork ‘in the works’~… silent evenings sway with inspiration, clinging onto the heart~beat of life~ early mornings blessed by peace, re~awaken joy of living inside a painting and a poem~

From: Corrine Bongiovanni — Aug 27, 2011

I think your creative juices must have been well nourished prior to composing this piece about crows and creativity. A spectacular piece of humor, insight, and sound information. Most appreciated!

From: Annette Waterbeek — Aug 27, 2011

Creativity is not something you can push although, in a high paced creative ad shop that is not an option… there is no understanding of real creativity…you have a set number of hours to GET IT DONE.

From: Tatjana Mirkov-Popovicki — Aug 27, 2011

Until recently, the food appeared in Jack’s beak upon a little bit of yelling. He is now being thought that one has to go out and do work to get food. That transition must feel scary…what do you mean there isn’t an endless amount of food just for me? I wish crows had nicer voices, or that they weren’t able to fly to the roofs just above bedrooms early in the mornings…

From: Nita Harper — Aug 27, 2011

A fellow artist told me today that your book of letters is her bible…I love reading the twice-weekly. Thanks!

From: Sue Geller — Aug 27, 2011

They break clams on your tiles because the tiles are perfect to break clams on!

From: Kathy Gillis — Aug 27, 2011

I love this….reminds me of my bluejays, me and my paintings!!! Oh, and Miss Muffin, my 12 yr.old kitty who rules us all!!

From: Dick Giddings — Aug 27, 2011

Creativity happens when you are thinking of something else.

From: R P Wekerle — Aug 27, 2011

Man is currently the ultimate and highest of the tool using animals. It would seem that we have a right, even a duty, to keep inventing more tools and applying them in an ever expanding array of creativity. In this ever-expanding universe, man may find his true meaning. It is not too difficult to think that he may be acting in a manner that is very much like the gods themselves — the original source of all the mystery — with all its potential for creative accomplishment and uncreative destruction. We need to be optimistic about the potential of creativity.

From: Suzanne Canner — Aug 28, 2011

Week after week for several years I have read and tried to absorb in that internal quiet space your words of wisdom which consistently feed my artistic soul and I thank you. Your recent topic of gratefulness touched a cord. Last week in the supermarket parking lot I waited patiently for my husband who is the gourmet cook in our family to return with his armful of carefully chosen goodies. My mind was ticking off the tasks accomplished on the to do list. Then I had an epiphany that I was no longer living in the NOW! My head was in the past and the future. I was off track. By chance ( I am not a believer of chance or coincidence) I looked up. There not five feet away from me was a beautiful red headed woodpecker in all his glory busily pecking away….totally in the moment. It was my learning lesson for the day. Watching Mr. Woodpecker I was brought into the present the now and I thanked G*D for allowing me this beautiful moment….I was grateful! And I returned to my painting that afternoon with renewed vigor and clarity of vision.

From: William Dolmage — Aug 28, 2011

What blessings artists have, to take time to paint in quiet gardens or in safe studios. More than overshadowing the terror of everyday life in other lands, this site, The Painter’s Keys, makes clear the potential for not just artists, but for all who would live freely and not be afraid to express their freedom. Thank you.

From: Jacque Blaeske — Aug 29, 2011

I love crows and your comments and advice!!

From: Tatjana Mirkov-Popovicki — Aug 30, 2011

We have a very creative young black bear visiting our neighborhood almost every day. He invented dropping in the middle of the day to check out neighbor’s BBQ party (no other bear has done this before, at least not in our area). Last night we heard him making loud noise and running around our backyard. We don’t have any food of fruit trees, so we believe that his latest invention has to do with feeding on our hot pepper plant. Judging from all the ruckus he made, this invention shall not be pursued.

     Featured Workshop: Firesign Art & Design Studio
083011_robert-genn Firesign Art & Design Studio workshops   The Workshop Calendar provides up-to-date selected workshops and seminars arranged in chronological order. 

Polar Propulsion

oil painting, 9 x 12 inches by Tina Whitfield

  You may be interested to know that artists from every state in the USA, every province in Canada, and at least 115 countries worldwide have visited these pages since January 1, 2013. That includes S. P. Leal of Sao Paulo, Brazil who wrote, “A period of boredom starts the mind to play at possibilities.” And also Lilija Gulbis of Sidney, BC, Canada, who wrote, “Become quiet, find contentedness, become valuable. These trump marketing every time, and as you learn to listen to your inner music, you can now ignore the marketers hawking their oils of snakedness.”    

Robert and Sara Genn Twice-Weekly Letters

Subscribe and receive the Twice-Weekly letter on art. You’ll be joining a worldwide community of artists.
Subscription is free.